Since this is a sporty t-shirt, I decided to go the "opposites attract" route and wear my frilliest floral skirt. I really loved this outfit, but I suspect others thought it was a bit weird. I'm okay with that.
Jacket: J.Crew Factory (exact)
T-shirt: some sports store at the mall
Skirt: Macy's (exact)
Shoes: Old Navy (option, option)